MAMAEARTH Charcoal Black Long Stay Matte Eyeliner Pencil | 11-Hour Smudge-Free Stay | Vitamin C Infused | Waterproof & Retractable | 0.01 Oz/0.35g

I bought this Eyeliner Pencil for my wife, and let me tell you, it's been a total hit! I'm no makeup expert, but I know she's picky about her eyeliner, and she's absolutely loving this one.First off, the color payoff is incredible! That deep, rich black is seriously stunning. She says it glides on super smoothly, and the matte finish looks so chic and sophisticated. No more smudgy raccoon eyes!What I really appreciate is that it's long-lasting. She puts it on in the morning, and it stays put all day, even through her busy work schedule and errands. No need for constant touch-ups, which is a huge win for her (and me!).She also mentioned that it's smudge-proof and waterproof, which is perfect for those unexpected tearjerker movies we occasionally watch. Happy to report, no panda eyes were spotted!Beyond the performance, she loves that it's from Mamaearth, meaning it's made with natural ingredients and is free from harmful chemicals. That's a big deal for both of us. Knowing it's dermatologically tested and safe for her sensitive skin gives us peace of mind.Here's what she loves (besides the fact that I got it for her, of course 😉 ):Intense Black Pigment: One swipe and you're good to go.Smooth Application: No tugging or pulling on the delicate eye area.Long-Wearing Formula: Stays put for hours without fading.Matte Finish: Gives a modern and sophisticated look.Natural Ingredients: Safe and gentle on the skin.Waterproof & Smudge-proof: Perfect for all-day wear.Easy to Sharpen: Maintains a precise tip for perfect lines.Honestly, for the price, this eyeliner is a steal. If you're looking for a high-quality, long-lasting, and safe eyeliner, look no further. My wife highly recommends it, and so do I! Five stars all the way!

Had my doubts when I bought this product, but it surprisingly met my expectations. Definitely long wear but it's not completely smudge proof. Would buy this again.

Good product. It doesn't irritate my eyes. But it does smudge little.

Irritating my eyes

Perfect kajal, easy to tightline with and doesn’t smudge or irritate my eyes

Good did not bother my allergies

It is good

Gives a smooth black finish. It bleeds but not bad