stilaStay All Day® Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Liner | Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner Pencil for Tightlining, Waterline & Smoky Eye Looks | 12-Hour Wear, No Budge & Fade-Proof

I think the gel liner is replacing Stila’s waterproof smudge stick as I can no longer find it in stock anywhere. I bought Damsel. It looks a slight bit darker than the original smudge stick. The gel glides on a lot more smoothly. I hate changing products and was suspicious of how I would like it. However, I think I love this more!! When applying, you can still smudge it if you want to, but if you don’t smudge it, it will set within 30-60 seconds. Super quick. Also the smudge stick used to run throughout the day, get under my eyes. The GEL stick STAYS PUT. NO more eyeliner dropping!! It looks as fresh as the moment I put it on 14 hrs ago. Super easy, moist, glides clean. For once, I actually like a product “improvement.” Easily washed off with soap and water or whatever you normally use. Is definitely waterproof. I will say I like the gold letters on the original vs the silver stars they put on the pencil if you care about how the pencil actually looks.

Application, colors and wearability are better than more expensive brands.

Big fan of Stila eyeliners, happy I can get real ones on Amazon now & not knock offs. Seems to last me all day, but once it sets in a minute or 2 there’s not much smudging to be done. Lasts a long time & will always repurchase!

This goes on smoothly and stays put for a while, but will smudge/run eventually by the end of the day. I wouldn't call it smudge-proof, and it would be better if it came with a sharpener. But overall, I will order it again.

I love stila products for their sustainability and stay-put look. I buy both the liquid liner and smudge liner to complement one another, and they work so well together. I don’t get any irritation, either, after wearing all day.

Clear bold liner for brows

I had high hopes for this but since half of it was smashed into the cap and the rest broke and fell to the floor, I guess I won't be trying it.And now I have to inconvenience myself to return it so I can get my money back.

it goes on so smoothly and is the right consistency