Review "Anthony La Vopa's biography of the young Fichte is a compelling exploration of the intellectual life and work of a controversial and important German philosopher, but it is much more than that.... La Vopa is a scholar of the eighteenth century, and Fichte provides an excellent opportunity to explore some of the constitutive themes of eighteenth-century Germany.... [The book] provides a new assessment of the formative forces behind and in Fichte's philosophical projects; it opens interesting venues into the study of eighteenth-century German society, and finally, it invites us to rethink the use of biography and historicism as forms and methodologies of historical writing." German Studies Review"Outstanding" Central European History Book Description This book, first published in 2001, is a biographical study of the German philosopher Johann Gottlieb Fichte from birth to the crisis in his university career in 1799 which explains thoroughly how Fichte's philosophy relates to his life experiences. It includes a reinterpretation of Fichte's political theory, his anti-Semitism, and his controversial views on gender and marriage. See all Product description
M**G
Misses the point
I'm not as put off by La Vopa's academicism as the last reviewer, though I agree that the book's coverage is absurdly narrow. What's really disturbing about this work is that La Vopa's understanding of Fichte's philosophy is impossible to justify. Fichte was not concerned with teaching people how to create a stable sense of self, as La Vopa thinks; he is out to explode all such constructions. And this isn't just the case with his later work. The very notion of the self-positing self and Fichte's teaching that the act of positing is the self makes the self into an ongoing and fluid activity without any fixed content. For an insight into Fichte's intellectual development the reader is far better off with Dieter Henrich's Between Kant and Hegel: Lectures on German Idealism, which treats it only in passing but with unsurpassed insight. For more conventional biography there's always the memoir in William Smith's nineteenth century The Popular Works of Johann Gottlieb Fichte, Tr., With a Memoir of the Author by W. Smith. (There are several reprint editions of this around.) Much of what you'll learn in La Vopa's work is simply wrong, alas. Between Kant and Hegel: Lectures on German IdealismThe Popular Works of Johann Gottlieb Fichte, Tr., With a Memoir of the Author by W. Smith
J**K
academia at its worst
The recent publication of biographies of philosophers in English, many by Cambridge, has filled a gap in the literature. Unfortunately this particular item is totally inadequate. First the style is pedantic and long-winded; apparently Mr. La Vopa had a sabbatical to fill up, a publication requirement to meet or just thought he might turn that dissertation into a book. Second, amazingly, it actually ends before Fichte did any of his most significant work! So it is unhelpful both as biography and commentary for any but the most narrowly focused of readers. Thirdly, at $65 it physically fell apart in my hands as I was reading it. I doubt if there are a dozen people in the English-speaking world to whom this book would be of interest.
Trustpilot
2 weeks ago
3 weeks ago