SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner #10 Matte Brown Black

Great so far, had it a few days, glides on and stays on. Forgot I was wearing it and rubbed my eyes, which did minimal damage to the make up. Very impressed.

Easy to put on, waterproof, little to no smudging (unless you rub your eyes).

I tested it for 8 hours and took a shower. Only one that has passed the test. I would suggest it come with a sharpener but the claims are true. It stays on well!!

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It is certainly worth the extra $$. Other pencils faded off or smeared, but this one stays put and stays dark. I do not like the "ink" on eyeliner and like the "pencil" look (it looks more dramatic and not "drawn on"), so this is perfect. Since eyeliner is the only makeup I wear most of the time, it is worth it to get a good brand, and this is it! -Tania

It's a great eyeliner, but it's only $14 at Sephora.