Aqua Resist Color Pencil - 1 Graphite by Make Up For Ever for Women - 0.04 oz Eyeliner

This eyeliner pencil stays in the waterline very well. It’s not good on the eyelids because it will smudge and transfer. If you need a great waterline eyeliner, this one works very well and is long lasting.

Saturated color that glides on easily and STAYS!

This is my second purchase of this make-up product. Worth every penny. You get what you pay for....not saying that some economical makeup products aren't any good or high price products are guaranteed to be wonderful. But this pencil I will continue to buy forever as long as I wear makeup. It is long lasting, heavy and dark, applies easily. I am glad I tried it. Thank you Amazon!

This eyeliner does not even remotely live up to its claims. The tip is thick and greasy, and the built-in sharpener is useless. Upon application the line smudged immediately, but I cleaned it up and waited for it to set. An hour later, I had thick black smudges covering my undereye areas even though I had applied tiny dots only in the lash line, as per Smitha Deepak, whose product advice I no longer trust after purchasing this useless eyeliner. I had horrible smudges after one hour of wearing the liner in my cold house (I keep the temperature at 62 degrees). I did not sweat or engage in any physical activity while wearing the liner. I look forward to dropping off the return at UPS.

This eyeliner is very good. Smooth going on and lasts all day. My only complaint is the cost. I think it is a little overpriced.

This pencil works pretty well for not smudging. I've had a hard time finding smudge-proof eye liner. It still smudges a little bit 2nd half of day but not terrible.

Favorite eye liner! I have Asian eyes and sweat a lot so I need the most water proof eye liner I can find that isn’t liquid. This has been my go to for years. Only thing I wished was that there was some warning that it was almost out of pencil, it comes as a surprise to me every time.

Disappointed that it smudged and smeared and did not stay in place. Also very thick when applying.