wet n wild Color Icon Cream Eyeliner Eyeshadow Multi-Stick, Moisturizing, Nourishing Velvety Cream-to-Powder Buildable & Blendable Formula, Cruelty-Free & Vegan - Royal Scam

I really loved this Wet n Wild multi-stick. It’s very easy to use, the color is beautiful, and it glides smoothly on the skin without irritation. I’ve used it as both eyeshadow and eyeliner, and it works great for both. It has good staying power and is perfect for everyday use or to carry in your bag. For the price, the quality is excellent. I highly recommend it.

I remember back in the early 90's going to Woolworths and there'd be these bins with cheap 99 cent makeup. Crazy colors like blue nail polish and black lipstick, colors that you didn't really see anywhere else back then, all piled up in these bins. They were all Wet N Wild, and I loved going through these bins and picking out a few items each time I visited. I always associated Wet N Wild with kitschy cheap makeup bins because of this, not that this was a bad thing. I also stopped seeing Wet N Wild after Woolworths went out of business and I always thought that was a shame, an end of an era. So imagine my surprise when I came across this! I've been on the hunt for the perfect shade of purple eyeshadow for years. Sephora had an eyeshadow pencil that had the perfect shade for me. The color was great, but the application was a bit on the chalky side. Still, it never failed to get compliments everytime I left the house with it on. Sadly, it was discontinued and I only bought one. So when that ran out, I tried in vain for years to find a suitable replacement. I started just buying any purple that remotely matched from any brand just to see if it'd work. I came across this and was surprised that 1., Wet N Wild was still a thing and 2., the color looked promising. Knowing my history with Wet N Wild and its bargain bin legacy, I didn't have high expectations on its quality. I bought this and another brand with a similar color that cost three times as much. I put this on my right eyelid and the expensive one on my left and whoa.... This pencil is AMAZING! The color glided on like silk. It wasn't chalky or hard or anything. It felt almost creamy. The pigmentation is rich, one pass and it was opaque and popping. I was able to glide over my eyelid a second coat and it went on so smoothly. No skin tugging, no pigment chunks falling off the pencil. Two coats and I couldn't stop staring at my eyes. The color is amazing. It was so much more vibrant than the more expensive brand. My only regret is not stocking up on more of these when they were in stock. Wet N Wild really threw me for a loop. I was expecting the bargain bin quality of my youth but this outperformed all my other color pencils. And this was by far the cheapest!! It's amazing that they kept the bin prices but seriously stepped up the quality! I'm definitely buying more and trying their other colors!

To be fair, I specifically searched for "super smudgy eyeliner." I used the black icon eyeliner/eyeshadow pencil as part of my makeup arsenal for a Rocky Horror Picture Show event. Super smudgy, grungy, and a little goes a loooooooooong way. If that's what you're looking for - YOU FOUND IT! A little "too much" for everyday use i think, but perfect for mosh pits. 🤷‍♀️ Im not sure if it comes in waterproof, mine was not. Was really easy to fix mistakes and I didnt have to scrub when removing my makeup. 👍 But also, with that, I wouldnt expect it to last through humid / high temps / moisture / long periods of time. Wasn't sticky, went on smooth. In terms of "drying," since its not liquid, doesnt require dry time but in terms of it "setting," it just simply doesn't. Smudgy. Smudgy. Smudgy.

The wet n wild Color Icon Multi-Stick is the MVP of my makeup bag. It’s creamy, dreamy, and glides on like it’s late for a red carpet. The shade gives just the right amount of shimmer, like your eyelids are subtly winking at everyone. It somehow manages to be both eyeliner and eyeshadow without having an identity crisis. Plus, it’s vegan and cruelty-free, so you can look fabulous with a clear conscience. It can crease without primer, but it dries quick, lasts a long time, and is super affordable! If you want a multitasking stick that’s basically the Swiss Army knife of glam, this one’s a keeper.

Pretty and a good price. It doesn't stay on very well would definitely recommend using a setting spray after applying these or topping with eyeshadow powder to keep in place

Finally an eye pencil that is a deep dark purple that's not super glittery. I've purchased so many eye pencils that promised to be a dark plum/wine color...but never was. This one though, is the first one I've ever purchased anywhere that is as dark as they say it would be. It is a beautiful dark wine/plum color. I love the quality of this pencil. It glides on so smoothly. And you can twist it up or twist it down and so it functions perfect. This was another problem I had with other pencils. They didn't have a way to sharpen them. They were completely useless as soon as the tip of it wore down. Because they wouldn't screw up they wouldn't screw down you couldn't sharpen them because it was like a plastic exterior around the color. I know other women must've had that trouble too. But this pencil won't need sharpening because of the design of it. It's nicely made. I'm going to order different colors because I really like the way this went on and stayed on.

I honestly bought this for my mom. She hates how the powdery eyeshadow always ends up broken and crumbling. These apply very smoothly, quickly and evenly on any type of skin. They are moisturizing as well. The product looks very nice on skin. Have not had the need to sharpen this yet, but I will update my review after. Good size for the price. No noticeable odd smell or anything, like normal shadow, but a creamy pencil. Wouldn't really use it as an eyeliner I don't think as the tip is not super fine, functions more as a broad application tool.

Like for real. This is amazing. They last a really long time. I mostly ONLY use this and blend it out. Like it is soooo pretty!! It’s buildable for a more dramatic look, or just a swipe or two for a more natural look. Sometimes I get influenced and buy other (expensive!) brands and I always come back to this. It’s creamy and stays on really well all day. I couldn’t love this little pencil more. For my bday - my husband bought me like 5 of them because I love them so much. I have 52 year old hooded eyes, and it never creases. Don’t sleep on this cute little pencil!