Eastland Women's Sadie Oxford, Black/White, 9.5 Medium US

I have ordered these shoes for almost 6 years in a row for my daughter to wear for her school uniform . They are tough and still soft and insole comfy . Also still a feminine not to bulky saddle Oxford so still light weight .

These are really comfortable. I sized up per the recommendations and they fit perfectly. A little snug but they are leather so they will stretch to fit once broken in. I love them. They are just what I wanted.

I'd gotten these for work shoes (desk job) and I'd wanted a "trial" pair of Oxfords before I made an investment on another brand. So far, I've worn these religiously five days a week, rain or shine, and they've held up incredibly well. There was hardly any stiffness / awkward breaking in, and I wear them with dress pants as well as jeans. Now, what I believe contributes to their longevity is that I polish them every week - usually at the end of the work week when I've taken them off for the day. Doing this I think will greatly improve the life of these shoes.

I was so excited to get another pair of black & white saddle oxfords after not having any since the early 1980’s during my cheerleading days in elementary school. After reading reviews about these shoes running small, I ordered a half size larger. I’m so glade I did!!! These shoes truly run a little on the smaller side so it would be a wise choice to consider that extra half size up. Sadly, if you have a wide foot, this is going to be a problem. Even with the extra length, the width was really snug. (No wide width for 9.5) After several hours of wearing them, the fit got much better. After removing my shoes after 13 hours, the condition of my shoes still looked great (see for yourself in my picture). Overall, allow shoes to break in and there won’t be much of a problem with comfort.*** Side Note: if you struggle with shoes irritating the back of your heel/ankle, let it be known there may be times you may feel it rubbing during the first hour of wearing for the first time.

Ok so when I first put these on I was a little worried. I’m a 9.5 and based on the reviews of these being true to size, I ordered a 9.5 shoe. When I first put them on, I had dress socks and they were entirely too tight. So I switched to the invisible socks like you wear with pumps and wore them around the house all day. They stretched and relaxed, and were SO comfortable that I hated to even take them off! If yours start off a bit snug, just keep in mind that leather does stretch and these will loosen with a breaking in period. These are my new favorite shoes and I can’t wait to wear them to car shows with my Classic muscle car to complete my retro outfits!

Perfect pair of saddle shoes! Looked for saddles specially with the brown bottoms for that authentic look. Recieved so many compliments already and have only worn them out twice. Super easy to clean, memory foam insole makes it very comfy to wear for a long time! I ordered a half size up and it was perfect. I'm a true size 9 and got a 9.5 with standard width.

A pinch larger than what anticipated, but I love them!! If you wear a 10 in narrow heels, I would recommend a 9 for a snug fit and a 9.5 if you don't mind a bit of wiggle room. They will crease in the front if you do not watch them (a bit too big), BUT they are such great quality!! Love! A must if you love the vintage/ retro look. Great price and product overall!

The shoes are really cute. They seem to be very nicely made. But they were only in my possession for half a day because the sizing is really off. Ordered my normal size and it was too short and too tight. Did not reorder because I didn't want to start a guessing game of what size would really work. If they had fit I'm thinking they probably would have been four or five stars.