Max Factor Excess Intensity Eyeliner, Longwear, 06 Excessive Brown, 7 g

The issue is that it twists up but doesn't go back in. This led to me trying to use it but it breaking as its too long at about 3mm and snapped. I can guarantee it stays put, when i finally found the broken bit it had drawn all over my sofa and I've had to book it to be cleaned.Great formula and colour but it's too brittle and breaks. The sharpen does nothing. Its so wide its impossible to draw a line that doesn't look like a toddler used my make up.If this was a normal pencil I could sharpen it would be my new favourite, alas I'm left thankful I took out a policy to clean my sofa incase of accident.

Absolute rubbish. It took me forever to get the cap off, it was on so tight i nearly broke my wrist trying to get it off. When I eventually got the cap off I attempted to put the eyeliner on. Everytime i tried to put it on it broke, so then i twisted it to bring up the stick and it broke again and this kept happening each time. This is supposed to be made by a well known cosmetic company but I certainly wont buy from them again.

Coverage is good and it lasts - however, you barely get an inch of colour stick, it snaps so easily no matter how gently you use it and, if you happen to twist it too far, you can’t reverse it back. Considering how expensive it is it’s terrible value.I’ve bought twice (in case the first experience was unusual) but no - won’t be buying again.

It lasts a long time and is easy to use. I bought even though the other reviews said that it was hard to use and that it doesn’t go back down once you click it up. But I find that you don’t click it any higher than you need. It’s good quality. But to be completely honest the Rimmel alternative is a better product, so I have gone back to that.

I've been using these for a while, buying them from my local supermarket. So when I saw them at half price here, I jumped at the chance. Generally, they're great for tight-lining the upper lid in a more natural way than liquid liner, and can be smudged well for a more natural blended look.Every time I've bought one elsewhere, it came with a clear cellophane wrapper and the "lead" inside the pencil has been perfectly flat. This one arrived without the wrapper and with clear angled use on the lead. So I'm almost certain it's not new. Not very hygienic if true!