Full description not available
R**N
Indispensible for anyone who really wants to understand the nexus of nutrition and health.
We are in a transition in nutrition and Dr. T. Colin Campbell has been in the forefront of this for many years, in particular since he stepped out of the shadows of scientific research and wrote a popular account of his life's biggest project, The China Study, complete with all the scientific references for those who are so inclined. That style continues. He addresses the general reader, but for those who are interested all the references are included.His combination of humility and plain common sense with scientific rigor is very appealing, and makes difficult material easily accessible. This book is the culmination of a lifetime of work and will be a go-to work of reference for many years to come. I would argue that before Campbell, there was no science of nutrition. Nutrition as most of us learned it was a set of normative assumptions based on the accident of historical discovery of different nutrients, but with Campbell began a rigorous scientific approach and he laid the foundation for a paradigm change that is slowly getting underway. This book brings everything together that was developed in The China Study and then fleshed out further in Whole, but here it is reframed once more as a direction for the future.Campbell teaches the practical meaning of a holistic approach to nutrition (he likes to call it wholistic) and this goes hand in hand with the more holistic approach to health in Lifestyle Medicine. The gist of it is that there really is a pretty clear picture emerging of what makes for a truly healthy diet, which Campbell has dubbed a Whole Foods, Plant-Based diet. Arguably, you could consider it "healthy vegan," but I like Campbell's term better, although "plant-based" is now being abused as much as vegan, so the consumer should be very conscious of the encroachment of commercial claims, which as usually are often misleading.The upshot is, if you're serious about health and nutrition, do not skip these books, they are the anchor in the science of nutrition for the now rapidly growing field of Lifestyle Medicine. It really does turn out that with only minor variations, there really is one diet that can help prevent most typical chronic diseases that are all caused by diet, such as heart disease, Type 2 Diabetes, kidney disease, and cancer to a degree also. Campbell's work started with his interest in liver cancer and again he brings all these strands together in this book.
T**U
It is true
Well written truth about our health and what pharmacies are doing.
G**S
A big picture view
Professor T. Colin Campbell has long been a major voice for plant-based nutrition. He has calmly and fearlessly gone against the nutrition establishment. He went into gentle but indefatigable battle armed not with the billion-dollar budgets of Big Pharma, Big Insurance, and Big Agriculture or the power of well-established hospitals, universities, and government bodies, but only with the ever-growing research evidence that Whole Food Plant-Based diets are the best way to halt the suffering and the horrible waste of nonhuman and human animals’ lives caused by animal-based and processed foods.Professor Campbell started life on his family’s dairy farm and began his research career studying animal-based protein, something that, at the time, he thought was a must for good health. The evidence he discovered changed his mind. Colin is probably best-known for his 2006 nonfiction best seller “The China Study” (https://www.socakajak-klub.si/mma/The+China+Study.pdf/20111116065942) named for a very large study he helped lead in China which suggested that moving away from animal-based foods was the best path to health.In a blurb on the back cover of Colin’s current book, “The Future of Nutrition,” David Feinberg, MD, head of Google Health, gets to the issue at the heart of what this book is about, “T. Colin Campbell’s latest masterpieceon whole food, plant-based nutrition is a must-read for anybody interested in understanding … how a proven lifestyle has become so controversial.”As Colin explains (p. 4), “controversy does not necessarily mean that contradicting evidence exists. The notion that smoking causes cancer was once viewed as extremely controversial, not because of an impressive body of evidence proving the healthfulness of tar and nicotine, but because it challenged prevailing norms. … Evidence that disputes the status quo will always be controversial.”Colin defines WFPB (whole food, plant-based) diets in 12 words (p. 7):1. Consume a variety of whole plant-based foods.2. Avoid consumption of animal-based foods.Two points stand out in this definition. First, no vegan junk food. Second, some people take “plant-based” to mean mostly plants with maybe some animal-based food every so often, what some call “flexitarianism.” Flexitarian is much better than a typical omnivore diet, but it’s not what Colin is talking about. The superiority of WFPB diets lies in their strong supply of antioxidants, complex carbs, and vitamins.Despite all the advances in health care and in knowledge about healthful lifestyles, the status quo is weak and becoming weaker. Even before COVID, U.S. life expectancy had began to decline, and even when earlier it was rising, much of that rise was due to management of disease, not prevention or treatment (pp. 18-21).Despite the research evidence for WFPB diets, most people, are confused for two reasons (p. 25). First, they do not see the strong link between diet and health, and second, even those who believe a powerful connection exists do not recognize the power of WFPB. They do not appreciate that “the more animal-based foods one eats, the less one consumes cancer-preventive plant-based foods packed with antioxidants, fiber, and other protective nutrients” (p. 51). For example, many people think that cancer is attributable more to genes and the impact of environmental chemicals, such as industrial pollutants, than to food (p. 145).I am involved in research in education, not health, but the book’s Chapter 7 resonated with me, as it addresses what Colin sees as limitations to what is considered valid research. He argues that while methods such as double-blind, placebo-controlled research have undeniable value, they may lead to excessive focus on discrete variables and technological solutions. Instead, we need an emphasis on context: “The ‘real world’ isn’t as easily controlled as a double-blind experiment conducted in a laboratory setting” (p. 163).Part of the solution in research, just as in WFPB, is wholism (see Colin’s earlier book “Whole”). The reductionism of most contemporary nutrition research yields incomplete pictures, because sooooo many factors impact health, not a few isolatable variables. For instance, the plants we eat contain hundreds of thousands of phytochemicals, and innumerable and constant interactions occur in the trillions of cells in a single human body (p. 171). Reductionist research results in “an elaborate system for collecting conflicting information that neither medical professionals nor the public know how to apply (pp. 201-202). Furthermore, how can nutrition science hope to grasp this complexity when budgets for nutrition research are dwarfed by those for pharmaceutical R&D.Chapter 10 offers recommendations. One of these is to value technology, but not to overvalue it. WFPB can be so simple. As Dr Greger of NutritionFacts.org often notes, companies cannot make much money selling broccoli, but they can make lots of money on high-tech supplements that claim to be even better than the original plant food: “WFPB is not a technological solution—quite the opposite, in fact—and so it generates little interest or funding support from the techno-scientific establishment” (p. 251).Some of Colin’s other recommendations include (pp. 256-257; 263-269):• Solid nutrition programs, including practicums, as part of the education of health professionals• Subsidies to support WFPB diets• Reflection on how we came to put so much faith in drugs and “high-quality” animal protein• Faith in the agency of each individual, as we can be role models via the choices we make every time we eat• Civil disagreement and “meet[ing] with people where they are (it’s the only place we can meet them)”• “[W]holism’s guiding principles—appreciation for context, communication, integration,” respecting and supporting Nature.In conclusion, while written for lay readers, “The Future of Nutrition” is not an easy read, although spice is added by the many stories Colin tells from his own experiences. Perhaps, the book’s greatest value lies in the perspective provided on how we got into our current mess by taking the wrong direction in our food journey, a direction that wreaks havoc on the environment and on our fellow Earthlings, human and otherwise.
C**L
Them's fighting words
The China Study was the first book of nutrition that really rocked my world — way back in 2004 — so I've read all of Dr. Campbell's books since (and listened to some of his lectures). The China Study transformed the lives of my family and many friends, helping us get trim and healthy and stay that way for 16 years.So when I got a notification from Amazon last night at 9 PM that this one was ready to read, I read it cover to cover in bed and hardly slept. Yeah, that wouldn't even be Dr. Campbell approved.It's pretty scientific and not the lightest of reads, but it fascinated me for two reasons:1. I like reading about the history of nutrition and how we arrived where we are. Following the science towards eating more plants and fewer animals is a tough business, full of drama rama. Meat and dairy has money and bare knuckle politics on its side, and plants have only science.2. Even with all my reading, I was thinking the main problem with meat and dairy is the saturated fat. I have heard Dr. Campbell express concern about animal protein but I heard it as a proxy for the fat for some reason. This book leaves no doubt about the role of animal protein in cancer and heart disease.Most of the very best scientists face lots of controversy, but Dr. Campbell faces it squared because bacon is delicious so who wants to give that up? But if you factor in not just our precarious health but the planet too, we have to cut way back just like we have to with coal.We're lucky to have a true great like Dr. Campbell among us to write first-rate books like this.
M**M
Informative read
Show's you what goes on in the scientific world. And the fight people have to through to get the information out that goes counter to what big corporations what is to know.
F**E
Wealth of Biology and Nutritional knowledge
This book is the best guide to nutrition for whole plant eating people and anybody else that is considering this diet. T Collin Campbell is the real thing and you are getting the knowledge from perhaps the worlds highest authority on the subject. After he is the man who wrote the China Study. T Collin Campbell is also a very talented writer in the way that he conveys knowledge and gets you to reflect on the science. There is something here for everybody irregardless of your present level of scientific knowledge.
S**.
absolut empfehlenswert
Dieses Buch ist ein "Muss" für jeden, der mehr wissen möchte, warum Erkenntnisse in der Wissenschaft entweder nicht stimmen oder warum die Wahrheit unterdrückt wird. Es absolut verständlich geschrieben von einem Mann der es wissen muss, da er in diesem System geforscht hat und immer wieder angeeckt ist, weil er eine andere Herangehensweise hatte, um Lösungen zu finden, als es die Doktrin der Universitäten vorsehen.
D**D
Nutrition classic
A classic tome on nutrition from Prof. Campbell.
A**E
Great book
We’ve read all his books and love them all, you can never learn enough about nutrition..
Trustpilot
3 weeks ago
2 months ago