Natural Farm Odor Free Jumbo Bully Sticks (12 Inch, 5 Pack), Extra-Thick Chews for Dogs, Fully Digestible 100% Beef Treats, Supports Dental Health, Keep Your Dog Busy with 50% Longer Lasting Chews…

I bought these because I forgot my dog's bully sticks at home and I'm traveling out of state. I was a little hesitant as my Toy Poodle can be picky with his treats. OMG, he loves these bully sticks and I do too. I love them because they don't have that foul odor that you get from the half eaten moist bully sticks that you usually do. Not sure if its due to the natural composition and no chemicals that lead to this but I decided to ditch he other brand and subscribe to this one. If your dog leaves bully sticks all over the place because he hides them and you thought it was gone, get these and you won't have everything smelling like beef pizzle.

My dog goes absolutely crazy for these bully sticks! I love that they’re truly odor-free — no weird smell lingering around the house. They keep my pup entertained for a long time, and I feel good knowing they’re all-natural with no additives. They’ve become my go-to for keeping her busy while I’m working or cooking. The consistency and quality are great, and I really appreciate the resealable bag that keeps them fresh. Worth every penny for a happy (and quiet!) dog.

WARNING: take it away from your dog when it gets smaller and can fit completely inside their mouth - my dog and my friends dog both had separate instances where they each had to go to the hospital bc of accidentally swallowing it and choking on it, my friends dog needed surgery to remove it and the doctors said there was a chance of internal bleeding so JUST MAKE SURE YOU TAKE THE BULLY STICK AWAY WHEN IT GETS TOO SMALL That being said, these are significantly stinky than any other bully sticks! Still has a smell but it’s sooo much less smelly than the other brands I’ve tried that claim to have no scent.

It is actually a pizzle stick. The sticks are indeed odor-free, and hard to chew. It took my puppy a while to make some moisture on it. It is surely long lasting. He gets tired fast with it. Unlike the Esophagus stick, (quite smelly), he can chew 1/3 in three hours, very addictive. But then he would skip his dog food for a whole day.

Dogs love them. I think they are just a bit too pricey.

My little shihpoo LOVES these bully sticks! Before he begins chewing them, he rolls around on them and throws them in the air and picks them up and puts them here and there and literally plays with them first. I take it as a sign that he’s so excited to have one. As with any treat, when it gets to be about 2 inches long I toss it and give him a new one. His teeth are like pearls and I completely attribute this to these wonderful treats. The thinner ones are perfect for him.

Joshua loves the collagen chews as well as the bully sticks from the same company. Joshua is an 11 year old golden retriever and it takes him about 2 hours to finish one. They don’t have an odor. Worth the money!

I've been buying these bully sticks for my 70 lb GDS/lab mix for two years and for the first 18 months I would have given them 5 stars. However the last three orders have not been up to the usual quality. Most of the sticks are so much thinner they won't even stay in my dog's chew stick holder. I thought at first it was just a fluke, but after the 3rd package of expensive mostly pencil-thin sticks, I'm done. They are also not as odor-free as they used to be, but I could overlook that if they weren't so thin now. My dog finishes these in about 5 minutes and used to chew on one for at least 20-25 minutes. Now I'm looking for another brand which makes me (and my dog) sad, especially after recommending Natural Farm bullies to many friends and my Facebook dog groups over the last two years. [Edit: Update, tried another brand of bully sticks but my dog wanted no part of them, so I went back to NF this week to try again, hoping the previous recent orders were just a fluke. This time I got the 12" one lb pack and they were great! I always cut the 12" sticks in half (easy to do with branch loppers) and she gets one 6" half each day in her bully stick holder. There were 10 sticks in this package and only one was thin. All the others were perfect size for her holder and she was a happy pup again! No odor at all so I was happy too. Hoping the quality issue has been corrected and I can count on these bully sticks again. Because of the improvement in my new order I edited my review and upped the star rating from two to four. If future orders continue to be high quality I'll come back and give it a five star!