Cloud Star Tricky Trainers Soft & Chewy Dog Training Treats 5 oz. Pouch, Liver Flavor, Grain-Free Low Calorie Behavior Aid with 310 treats

Let me just tell you, I gave it five stars for flavor but I have never actually tasted them. But, according to my dog Jack, they are delicious. My dog Jack will do anything for these and it’s frankly embarrassing. He should have more self-esteem and self worth. My goodness Jack, have some pride man.

My Pom googled down all the flavors when I first opened the bags—then refused to touch them again. The « chewy” treats immediately grow hard and stale once exposed to air, so they didn’t even smell good enough to eat again, nor could his13-year old teach manage them anyway. Surprising, because the functional chews do stay chewy, so I cut those down to smaller bits.

These treats are great for training, however there is no need for maple syrup. So many dogs now have diabetes and cancer and should not have any kind of sugar.

I bought these in the peanut butter flavor for helping to train my new boxer pup. The small size and low calorie count made this an ideal option for his puppy kindergarten and puppy obedience classes.So far, he likes them ok, but they are not soft enough for a quick "yes!" and they aren't "smelly" and enticing enough to grab his attention fully enough for the training purposes. I am now using softer pill pouches and tearing pieces off in order to entice him int a new command. Once he is free of the distraction, then I can continue to use these Tricky Trainers as reinforcements.

My dog likes these. I have them in my bedside chest and she gets a couple before she settles down into bed. They are very small which is what we wanted so she won't gain weight but still feels like she is getting her nighttime snack. When she was a puppy, we used them as a reward for potty training with her.

I really like cloud star treats. I decided to try the peanut butter flavor to mix things up. My dog loves them, but really she’ll eat anything. These are a bit more crumbly than the liver flavor. Are usually break cloud star treats and half which doesn’t work so well with these ones. I’ll go back to ordering the liver flavored treats

The most important thing to remember is what you feed your pet is their health and longevity.FEED AND TREAT HEALTHY!!! NO JUNK!!Great product and price. We use these to show our adoptable dogs off with the clients. They all love this treat and so will your dogs!!!

These are FABULOUS training treats for dogs of any size/age. Slightly “chewy” but dry to hands and perfect to keep a pocket if needed without staining fabric etc. Great size for a Chihuahua to a giant breed dog but may need a few more each time! I’ve been using these for a few years and ALL dogs love them.

My 5 month old Frenchie loves these soft treats. They are the perfect size for training, and can easily be split in half if even smaller sizes are desired.